Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli: A Must-Read Romance That Redefines Modern Love

If you’re looking for a book that will make you laugh, swoon, and reflect on the complexities of love, Too Good to Be True by Prajakta Koli is your next must-read.

This debut novel has taken 2025 by storm, becoming one of the year’s bestsellers and earning rave reviews for its fresh take on modern romance. Whether you’re a fan of witty rom-coms or simply love a good love story, this book is a delightful escape into the world of Avani and Aman—a couple whose journey will leave you smiling long after you’ve turned the last page.

What Makes Too Good to Be True So Special?

Prajakta Koli, better known as MostlySane, has already made a name for herself as a digital creator, actor, and climate activist. With her debut novel, she proves that her storytelling prowess extends beyond the screen. Too Good to Be True is a heartfelt, humorous, and deeply relatable exploration of love, self-discovery, and the messy beauty of modern relationships.

The story follows Avani, a bookstore employee and romance novel enthusiast, who meets Aman—a man who seems to have stepped straight out of her favorite love stories. He’s charming, successful, and almost too perfect. But as their relationship unfolds, Avani begins to question whether Aman is truly the dream guy he appears to be or just too good to be true.

Why You’ll Fall in Love with This Book

1. Relatable Characters: Avani is a protagonist you’ll instantly connect with. She’s witty, flawed, and navigating the ups and downs of love and life in a way that feels incredibly real. Aman, on the other hand, is the kind of character who keeps you guessing—is he perfect, or is there more beneath the surface?58

2. A Fresh Take on Romance: While the book plays with classic rom-com tropes, it also subverts them, offering a refreshingly honest portrayal of modern relationships. It’s not just about finding love—it’s about learning to trust yourself and embrace vulnerability

3. Humor and Heart: Prajakta Koli’s signature wit shines through in every page. The banter between characters is sharp and hilarious, but the story also has moments of deep emotional resonance that will tug at your heartstrings.

4. A Love Letter to Book Lovers: Set in a bookstore, the novel is a celebration of stories and the magic they bring to our lives. If you’ve ever lost yourself in a book, you’ll find a kindred spirit in Avani.

5. Original Soundtrack: Adding to the book’s unique charm is its original soundtrack, Saanvare, which complements the story beautifully. It’s a multisensory experience that enhances the emotional depth of the narrative.

Why This Book Is Perfect for You

If you’re a fan of authors like Sally Thorne or Emily Henry, you’ll adore Too Good to Be True.

It’s a contemporary romance with a distinctly Indian flavor, offering a fresh perspective on love, family, and self-discovery. The book’s themes of vulnerability, trust, and personal growth make it more than just a love story—it’s a journey of finding yourself while navigating the complexities of relationships.

Too Good to Be True is more than just a romance novel—it’s a celebration of love in all its messy, imperfect glory. Prajakta Koli’s debut is a testament to her talent as a storyteller, blending humor, heart, and authenticity into a narrative that feels both familiar and groundbreaking. Whether you’re a longtime fan of Prajakta or new to her work, this book is a must-read for anyone who believes in the power of love and stories.

So, grab your copy of Too Good to Be True and immerse yourself in a world where love is anything but predictable.